Key Factors Indicating Trust or Corporation Treatment
This checklist summarizes the primary factors that the IRS and US courts consider when determining whether a civil foundation will be treated as a trust or a corporation for US tax purposes. For each factor, it is indicated whether the presence of that characteristic suggests classification as a trust or as a corporation.
Checklist of Classification Factors
| Factor | Suggests Trust | Suggests Corporation |
| Purpose and Activities | Primarily to conserve or manage property for beneficiaries; passive investment or holding assets | Active conduct of business; operating a trade or business |
| Control and Management | Trustee, Founder, chairman and/or Board manage property for beneficiaries; beneficiaries have limited or no control | Board of directors or similar body controls operations for benefit of the “entity”; members/shareholders may have voting rights |
| Beneficiaries vs. Owners | Clearly defined beneficiaries who receive benefits from trust assets | Shareholders or members own interests in the entity and may receive dividends or distributions |
| Legal Title to Assets | Trustee holds legal title to assets for the benefit of beneficiaries | Entity itself (corporation) owns assets in its own name |
| Ability to Contract | Trustee enters into contracts on behalf of trust | Corporation enters into contracts in its own name |
| Perpetual Existence | Generally limited by the terms of the trust instrument or applicable law (may terminate or dissolve) | Corporation typically has perpetual existence unless dissolved (but see Estate of Swan, 24 T.C. 829 (1955), rev’d. on other grounds, 57-2 USTC ¶11,714 (2d Cir.) in which case the Founder would revoke the foundation). |
| Transferability of Interests | Interests in trust are generally not freely transferable; subject to trust terms | Shares/membership interests are generally transferable (subject to corporate bylaws) |
| Fiduciary Duties | Trustee owes fiduciary duties to beneficiaries | Directors/managers owe fiduciary duties to corporation and sometimes to shareholders |
| Formalities and Governance | Governed by trust instrument; less formalities required | Subject to statutory requirements (e.g., meetings, minutes, filings) |
| Profit Motive | May be for benefit of beneficiaries, not necessarily a profit-oriented entity | Formed to earn profits for shareholders/members |
| Tax Treatment | Taxed as a trust (grantor, simple, or complex trust rules); income may be taxed to grantor or beneficiaries | Taxed as a corporation (subject to corporate income tax or pass-through treatment if elected) |
| Ability to Raise Capital | Limited ability; generally through gratuitous contributions from settlor or beneficiaries as opposed to contributions in exchange for ownership certificates | Can issue shares, raise capital from investors |
| Distribution of Profits/Assets | Distributions made according to trust instrument to beneficiaries, Founder may have authority to affect distributions. | Dividends/distributions made to shareholders or members according to corporate rules |
Summary Guidance
- If the foundation’s primary purpose is to manage property for identified beneficiaries with limited business activity, it is likely to be treated as a trust.
- If the foundation operates a business, has transferable interests, perpetual existence, and is managed by a board, it is likely to be classified as a corporation.
- In ambiguous cases, the IRS applies a “facts and circumstances” test, weighing all factors to determine classification.
This publication is provided by Greenspoon Marder LLP is issued for informational purposes only and is not intended to be construed or used as general legal advice nor a solicitation of any type. Please contact the author(s) or your Greenspoon Marder LLP contact if you have any questions regarding the currency of this information. The hiring of a lawyer is an important decision. Before you decide, ask for written information about the lawyer’s legal qualifications and experience.
